The following is the Rutland Railroad/Railway’s milk car roster from 1920 until 1961.
| Number | Builder | Date | Type | Notes |
| 300-328 | Milk | Rutland rebuilds 1918-19 | ||
| 329-336 | Merchants Despatch Transport | 1914 | Milk | |
| 337 | American Car and Foundry | 1904 | Milk | Wood, steel underframe, ex baggage car 193, rebuilt 1918, retired 1961 |
| 338 | American Car and Foundry | 1904 | Milk | Wood, steel underframe, ex baggage car 194, rebuilt 1919, sold for scrap April 1957 |
| 340-349 | Merchants Despatch Transport | 1924 | Milk | Wood, steel underframe |
| 350-355 | 1925 | Milk | Wood, steel underframe – ex DL&W purchased in 1954 | |
| 383-399 | Milk | Wood, steel underframe, ex-reefers rebuilt to milk cars 1926-27 from Rutland 1800-series reefers. |
Sources:
- Passenger Cars of New England, Vol 3 – Robert A. Liljestrand & David R. Sweetland
- Railway Milk Cars, Vol 2 – Robert A. Liljestrand & John Nehrich
- The Rutland, 60 Years of Trying, Vol 1 – Robert Nimke